Incorporating the Secret Ingredient

There are two secret ingredients in this delicious fudge recipe. To incorporate the secret ingredient into this Butterfinger fudge recipe, you’ll need candy corn! Yes, you read that right, candy corn! CANDY CORN has a marshmallow flavor and works well with the peanut butter to create the perfect copycat Butterfinger candy bar flavor. Now, onto another unexpected ingredient that adds a delightful crunch to this already irresistible fudge – Corn Flakes Cereal. Maintaining their crispy texture even when mixed into the fudge, cornflakes bring a unique element to the table that surprises and delights with every bite. The combination of smooth, rich fudge and the crispiness of Corn Flakes creates a perfect harmony of flavors and textures.

How to Make Easy Butterfinger Fudge

If you love the Classic Butterfinger Candy Bar, then you are going to love this fudge recipe! This fudge is filled with the perfect amount of peanut butter flavor and added crunch from the cornflakes; all encased in a coating of creamy milk chocolate.

HOLIDAY BUTTERFINGER FUDGE INGREDIENTS LIST-full printable recipe below in recipe card

• 3 cups candy corn
• 1 cup smooth peanut butter
• 1 (14-ounce) can sweetened condensed milk
• 1 (11-ounce) bag of white chocolate chips
• 2½ cups cornflakes, lightly smashed
• 2 (10-ounce) bags of Ghirardelli milk chocolate melting wafers

CANDY CORN FUDGE INSTRUCTIONS

1. Line a 9×13-inch pan with foil hanging off the sides, spray with nonstick cooking spray.
2. Add candy corn and peanut butter to a medium saucepan.
3. Turn the stove to medium-low and heat the candy corn mixture until the candy is melted (about 7 minutes), constantly stirring.
4. Add the sweetened milk, cook for 3 minutes, and stir every 30 seconds.
5. Add the white chocolate chips and stir until everything melts together.
6. Stir in the cereal and evenly spread it in the prepared pan.
7. Cool on the counter for 15 minutes, refrigerate until hardened, and cut into bars.
8. Line a cookie sheet with parchment paper and set aside.
9. To a medium microwaved safe bowl, add one bag of the milk chocolate wafers.
10. Heat 1 minute, stir until creamy.
11. Dip bars in the melted chocolate and place them on the prepared cookie sheet.
12. When the chocolate is low, add the remaining bag, heat for 1 minute, stir until creamy, and dip the remaining fudge bars on the prepared cookie sheet. Makes 20 (1¼x 3 inch) Bars

Collection of Fudge Recipes

Want to create a Christmas fudge tray? When it comes to holiday treats, there’s nothing quite like a festive fudge tray to bring joy and sweetness to the season. From creamy chocolate to nutty peppermint, the possibilities for creating delicious fudge are endless. But with so many recipes out there, how do you choose which ones to include on your Christmas fudge tray? Look no further! Below is a selection of easy-to-make delicious fudge recipes. Whether you’re a novice cook or a seasoned baker, there’s something for everyone on this delectable list. CLICK HERE FOR THE ENTIRE RECIPE COLLECTION→FUDGE RECIPES

• FRUITCAKE FUDGE
• PAYDAY FUDGE
• PRALINE FUDGE
• RED WINE FUDGE
• PEPPERMINT PATTY FUDGE
• PINEAPPLE UPSIDE-DOWN CAKE FUDGE

MELTING WAFERS VS CHOCOLATE BARS

MELTING WAFERS: If you choose to use melting wafers, I highly recommend choosing Ghirardelli. DO NOT USE candy melts of any brand, and not chocolate-flavored almond bark. I used the Ghirardelli milk chocolate melting wafers. I love how easy they are to use. The wafers melt beautifully without having to add any additional fat.

CHOCOLATE BAR: Chop 1 cup of your favorite dark chocolate bar and add 1 tablespoon of coconut oil. Heat for 30 seconds, stir, and continue heating until the chocolate is melted and, when stirred, is creamy.

HOW TO STORE BUTTERFINGER FUDGE

Key points about storing Butterfinger fudge

• Airtight container: Always use an airtight container to prevent the fudge from drying out or absorbing odors from other foods. 
• Room temperature vs. refrigerator: While room temperature is fine for short-term storage, the fridge is better for longer shelf life. 
• Wax paper layers: If you plan to store the fudge for a long time, place wax paper between the layers to prevent them from sticking together.

WHY IS THERE CANDY CORN IN THE FUDGE?

Candy corn has a sweet, buttery, vanilla flavor. These flavors, combined with peanut butter, offer the perfect alternative to an actual Butterfinger Candy Bar.

• Sweet: The high sugar content from the marshmallow and corn syrup gives candy corn its initial sweet taste.
• Buttery: The melting process releases volatile compounds that enhance the buttery notes.
• Vanilla: The vanilla adds depth and complexity to the flavor.

Topping Alternative—Butterfinger Crumbles

To elevate this Butterfinger fudge to the next level, consider topping it with Butterfinger crumbles for an added burst of flavor and crunch. The combination of creamy fudge and crispy Butterfinger pieces is sure to please a crowd at any gathering or event. Plus, the extra layer of texture will make each bite even more irresistible.

Holiday Goodie Tray

Encourage sharing and celebrate the season with a variety of homemade treats. The vibrant colors and flavors of this Christmas Butterfinger fudge make it a standout addition to any holiday goodie tray. Create a holiday goodie tray you can be proud of, and your friends will forever keep bugging you to make it! Below are a few of my favorite Christmas Candy Recipes. CLICK HERE FOR THE FULL COLLECTION→CANDY/FUDGE

• EASY HOMEMADE SOFT APPLE CIDER CARAMELS
• OLD FASHIONED DIVINITY
• GRANDMA’S HOMEMADE PEANUT ROUNDERS
• STRAWBERRY CHEESECAKE TRUFFLES
• PUMPKIN SPICE ALMOND ROCA
• MICROWAVE PEANUT BRITTLE

LATEST POSTS

• Easy Butterfinger Fudge
• Garlic and Herb Swirl Bread
• How to Make Ambre and Marbled Decorated Pretzels
• Leftover Pecan Pie Bread Pudding
• Homemade PayDay Fudge Bars

Elevate your holiday treat game with this game-changing Butterfinger fudge recipe. From the decadent fudge base to the unexpected secret ingredients of candy corn and cornflakes, this fudge is sure to be a hit at any holiday gathering. Whether you’re looking for a teacher gift, a hostess gift, or a tasty addition to your holiday goodie tray, this Butterfinger fudge is a perfect choice. Share the love and spread holiday cheer by gifting this irresistible treat to friends and family this season. Indulge in the sweet surprise of this fudge and make this holiday season one to remember.💗Sheryl