With THREE kinds of ice cream, FIVE types of cookies and SIX different treats to roll on the ice cream sandwiches the possibilities are endless. Below, you will find six of my favorite ice cream sandwich combinations. Including delicious ice cream sandwich flavors like S’mores, Almond Joy, Orange Creamsicle, and more! Below are just suggestions, customize your ingredients to your guests.

CREATE A SIGNATURE ICE CREAM SANDWICH!

You’ve heard of parties serving their unique signature party drink. Join in on the fun and create a party signature ice cream sandwich. Customize it to go with your party theme.

CUSTOMIZE EVERYTHING TO FIT YOUR CELEBRATION THEME!

With just a few color coordinated items it’s easy to transform an ice cream sandwich bar to fit any celebration theme.

The Cookies

The cookies you choose can be either homemade or store bought. It goes without saying, homemade cookies are ALWAYS better.

The Ice Cream

I recommend using store bought ice cream for your ice cream sandwiches. Even though the flavor of homemade ice cream is above and beyond store bought, homemade ice cream tends to be very soft and melts faster than store bought ice cream.

Ice Cream Sandwich Assortment Ideas

OATMEAL COOKIE ICE CREAM SANDWICHES

Seeing my Granddaughter’s eyes light up when I took these delights out of the freezer was a thrill. I love taking something simple and making it into something new. The perfect treat for those jump in the pool hot summer days! No special ingredients. Just toppings you have leftover from baking or making ice cream Sundays. Of course it’s all about the crispy on the outside and tender on the inside buttery cookie! CLICK HERE FOR THE RECIPE→OATMEAL COOKIE ICE CREAM SANDWICHES

CHOCOLATE DIPPED ORANGES ICE CREAM SANDWICHES

Everything you love about oranges dipped in chocolate. This one is fun because you can choose to combine two cookies ( Triple Chocolate Brownie Cookies and Orange Cake Cookies-recipes below) or use two of each. Whichever combo you choose add a big scoop of chocolate ice cream to give you that Chocolate Dipped Oranges flavor. CLICK HERE FOR THE RECIPE→CHOCOLATE DIPPED ORANGES ICE CREAM SANDWICHES

ORANGE CREAMSICLE ICE CREAM SANDWICHES

These ice cream sandwiches are made with a chewy easy to make Orange Cake Cookie and vanilla ice cream. I am a super fan of Orange Creamsicles. Actually in my day they were called 50/50 bars. They were my popsicle of choice to get from the ice cream truck. This brings back memories of running in the sprinklers and sitting on the front steps with my popsicle. Perfect memories of summer. CLICK HERE FOR THE RECIPE→ORANGE CREAMSICLE ICE CREAM SANDWICHES

NEAPOLITAN ICE CREAM SANDWICHES

Vanilla, chocolate and strawberry. These flavors were meant to be together. Take a Vanilla Cookie add strawberry ice cream and top the ice cream with a triple chocolate brownie cookie. Simply perfection! This mini ice cream sandwich is the perfect little treat to serve at the end of a delicious meal. Sit outside and enjoy a cool refreshing dessert. CLICK HERE FOR THE RECIPE→NEAPOLITAN ICE CREAM SANDWICHES

MONSTER ICE CREAM SANDWICHES

Made with homemade Graham Cracker Cookies and filled with vanilla ice cream. The star of the show are all the toppings. Like, nuts, toasted coconut, toffee bits and mini chocolate chips. Simple but completely addicting and delicious! To me whenever I see monster in the title of a baked good or dip that means I have the freedom to add whatever my heart desires. Like this ice cream sandwich. Use up leftover morsels you have in the pantry. CLICK HERE FOR THE RECIPE→MONSTER ICE CREAM SANDWICHES

ALMOND JOY ICE CREAM SANDWICHES

Transform your favorite candy bar into a summer treat! Made with two homemade Triple Chocolate Brownie Cookies, a big scoop of vanilla ice cream, and rolled in a combination of toasted coconut and chopped almonds. The perfect poolside dessert. CLICK HERE FOR THE RECIPE→ALMOND JOY ICE CREAM SANDWICHES

CARROT CAKE ICE CREAM SANDWICHES

Transform your favorite cake into an ice cold refreshing ice cream sandwich. This ice cream sandwich starts with delicious chewy Carrot Cake Cookies and are filled with cold and creamy vanilla ice cream. But the deliciousness doesn’t stop there. Next you roll your ice cream sandwich in a combination of toasted coconut and chopped nuts. The cookies are made with tons of freshly shredded carrots, oats, brown sugar and a touch of cinnamon. What better way to make the perfect Carrot Cake Ice Cream Sandwich? CLICK HERE FOR THE RECIPE→CARROT CAKE ICE CREAM SANDWICHES

S’MORES ICE CREAM SANDWICHES

The perfect treat when it’s too hot for a campfire and you’re craving a s’mores…. make it into an ice cream sandwich! This ice cream sandwich is made with homemade Graham Cracker Cookies. Then filled with chocolate ice cream and rolled in mini mallow bites. The perfect addition to a summer evening. CLICK HERE FOR THE RECIPE→S’MORES ICE CREAM SANDWICHES

Latest Posts

• Decadent Brownie Pie
• Semi Homemade Pumpkin Pie Truffles
• Apple Butter Cinnamon Roll Bundt Cake
• Easy Homemade Soft Apple Cider Caramels
• Easy Spice Cake Mix Cookies with a Maple Glaze